THE JOURNAL

The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings of Power, series one, 2022. Photograph courtesy of Prime Video
Wyverns? Krakens? Realms ruled by sorcery? I know what you’re thinking: “Surely all the magic, monsters and medieval nonsense paraded through Game Of Thrones or Lord Of The Rings has zero application to my life?” If you’re a fantasy buff, this is a demurral you have probably heard before. We all know a well-read lover of fiction who turns up their nose at the mere suggestion of cracking open a fantasy book, even a critically acclaimed one.
So, what are the unconverted missing out on? A lot, it turns out. I contend that the genre has a lot more real-world utility than you might initially think. At which point it becomes incumbent upon me to scale the nearest mountain and hold aloft a burning sword, while loudly proclaiming, “Harken, all you valiant young warriors! As you set out upon the MMORPG we call ‘modern life’, there is valuable XP to be gained from reading an epic fantasy tale...” Read on to learn more.
01.
Fantasy holds a mirror up to the real world
Everyone judges a book by its cover, and fantasy probably more so than most genres. Maybe it’s the eldritch illustrations, which depict some sort of grim feudal setting. Or the melodramatic title, rendered in a lurid swirl of bladed, thorny fonts. Perhaps it’s the ubiquitous chain of initials in the author’s name, not to mention the formidable heftiness of most tomes. While such design tropes are the very things fans are drawn to, they also act as a double-edged sword, if you will, and for many readers present a massive turn-off.
Before you begin this quest, it’s important to put aside any notions you might hold of the fantasy genre. We have come a long way since the “ye olde adventures” that took their cues (and, ahem, the bulk of their ideas) from Mr JRR Tolkien’s Lord Of The Rings saga. Rather, good modern fantasy allows us to engage with concepts that might otherwise seem either too highfalutin or difficult to articulate in a real-world scenario.
02.
Fantasy and sci-fi are two sides of the same coin
Proper sci-fi takes a high concept – say, how a specific technological advancement might play out if taken to its most logical extreme – and uses this as a device to critique aspects of our society. It does not matter if the actual “science” is nebulous or unsound, so long as the story and its characters are grounded in some human truth. When it works well, it often proves prescient. It offers a warning of what might be – and what we might become.
Fantasy is the flipside to this. Instead of futuristic ideas, it leverages tropes of the past – our histories, cultures and politics – and reimagines them through a fantastical lens. All the knights and dragons, or, in the case of my book, The Wyvern And The Wolf, samurai, ninja and monsters (unapologetic plug), merely serve as colourful backdrops to tell universal stories. So, rather than swashbuckling escapism, great fantasy asks us to face the problems and injustices we continue to struggle with in real life – war, inequality, disease, classism, racism, environmental destruction. Take your pick.
“Rather than swashbuckling escapism, great fantasy asks us to face the problems and injustices we continue to struggle with in real life”
In Mr George RR Martin’s bestselling A Song Of Ice And Fire series, the warring houses of Westeros’ failure to recognise the existential threat posed by the White Walkers could be interpreted as a metaphor for our own global leaders’ stubborn recalcitrance to address climate change. We have heard the warnings, we have seen the signs and, just like Queen Cersei, we have been presented with the undeniable proof. Yet still we do nothing. By raising the stakes, fantasy can put a spotlight on the self-destructive tendencies of humankind.
03.
Heroes are often the worst kinds of villains
One only has to wander through the streets of London, the American South or Australia’s cities to find old monuments to venerated heroes of the past still standing. Unsurprisingly, most of them are of men. And very few of these roguish characters would be considered true heroes by any modern benchmark of valour or chivalry. In many cases, they were responsible for suppressing native populations by the most brutal methods. Yet, there they are – the bronze busts of butchers, tyrants and murderers, overseeing the spot in the park where you sit down to have lunch.
This is not intended as some overly woke mediation on why we must pull down colonial-era statues, even if I would argue there is a moral imperative to do so. It is merely to highlight how history often presents us with heroes who were more like villains.
“Villains don’t have to be the knife-wielding, murderous kind… These monsters often come in the guise of friends, lovers, colleagues or seemingly benevolent mentors”
Likewise, in the best contemporary fantasy novels, such as the grim, taut works of Mr Joe Abercrombie or Mr Richard K Morgan, we find a nuanced exploration of the moral ambiguity of protagonists who repeatedly lie, cheat, steal and kill with varying degrees of remorse.
In real life, of course, villains don’t have to be the knife-wielding, murderous kind. The scariest variety are often too smart for that. These monsters often come in the guise of friends, lovers, colleagues or seemingly benevolent mentors. Sometimes they can espouse all the same virtues and appear aligned to the same goals, as long as it serves to elevate their own status or agenda. Eventually, one way or another, their mask will slip.
04.
Our world is as fantastical as any fiction
If fantasy still isn’t real enough for you, I would invite you to gaze at an elephant. Take a brief moment to contemplate just how alien its physiology appears to be. Or what about an octopus? A pangolin or a platypus? Or any of the other unlikely, otherworldly creatures that pop up in the most benign of Sir David Attenborough’s documentaries?
Now just marvel over the confluence of evolutionary factors that led to you – a bipedal mammalian primate – existing right now, bequeathed by your ancestors with the intrinsic dexterity to execute complexities, such as painting, playing the piano or writing fiction.
Yes, fantasy novels are full of many bizarre faunae, but are they any more peculiar than some of the denizens that occupy this planet? Recognising that they are not stresses the importance of preserving our strange world and its increasingly precarious grip on life.
05.
Fantasy can give us hope for the future
When done well, fantasy allows us to explore a paradox that plagues humanity – the ongoing tension between advancement and atavism. By that I mean that, even as our scientific and technological prowess expands, we still find ourselves devolving into tribalism and barbarism. What’s more, the success of Game Of Thrones perhaps reveals our innate desire to be entertained by such conflict. How can we stop being motivated by conflict when it forms the basis of all our storytelling?
In his efforts to understand the awful, inexplicable silence of the universe, the physicist Mr Enrico Fermi theorised a kind of unknown immutable barrier, be it evolutionary, self-imposed or extraterrestrial, which he dubbed the Great Filter. Once triggered, it would act as a “ceiling” that curtailed any sentient civilisation from flourishing beyond the limits of its home planet, much less lasting long enough to make contact with another. I am certainly not the first to wonder if the pursuit of conflict is our in-built flaw.
If we read enough good fantasy, who knows? Maybe we will learn strategies for overcoming this. I live in hope. At the very least, it sure sounds like a cracking read.
Mr Nicholas Snelling is the author of the high fantasy novel The Wyvern And The Wolf