What To Wear To The In-Laws’ This Thanksgiving

Link Copied

5 MINUTE READ

What To Wear To The In-Laws’ This Thanksgiving

Words by Jim Merrett

44 minutes ago

Ben Stiller and Robert De Niro in “Focker-In-Law” (2026). Photograph courtesy of Paramount Pictures

Whether it’s Thanksgiving, Christmas, Diwali or Hanukkah, family gatherings can be fun. But they can also be fraught. Impossible expectations, knotty dynamics and a break from your everyday routine – and that’s just the dress code. Things get even more complicated if it’s your other half’s family you’re visiting. Multiply your worries by the desire to impress in laws and it all sounds like the setup for a Jonathan Franzen novel.

One person who has faced exactly this conundrum is Tony Salerno, MR PORTER’s Senior Marketing Manager. He’s based in New York but recently travelled to the Midwest to meet his partner’s parents for the first time. How did it go? And, more importantly, what was he wearing?

“In my black Jacquemus cargo pants and a yellow bomber jacket, I landed in the Indianapolis airport with one goal: to stand out,” he says. “As I came down the escalator, the parents, whom I had heard plenty about, easily spotted me. In hindsight, the man holding a sign with my name (upside down, naturally), could only have been my partner’s famously quirky father. They welcomed me with a big, unmistakably Midwesterner hug. A reminder that sometimes, dressing to be seen is just as important as dressing to impress.”

Assuming needing to be located at a transportation terminal is less of a concern for some of us, here’s expert advice on what to wear when you visit your in-laws.

01. The ground rules

First impressions matter, as we all know. Therefore, given the potential gravity of this situation, you should put a lot of thought into what you’ll be wearing when you arrive. (Also, be prepared for an in-depth breakdown of the A-roads you used to get there, should you be encountering parents of a pre-Google Maps generation.)

“First and foremost, it’s about understanding your audience, being respectful and humble, while also being true to yourself,” Salerno reports, based on recent reconnaissance. “Like most of life, you don’t want to be underdressed just as much as you don’t want to be overdressed. Elevated enough to show you have your life together, but not that you’re trying to steal the spotlight. Ultimately, you’re in their home, trying to show you’re worthy of their family’s love and respect.”

“This depends massively if you have met them before,” says Lauren Cochrane, senior fashion writer for The Guardian, on dressing to impress. “Do they know your style? Or is it going to raise eyebrows? In general, it is best to play it a little safe and think practically, as in what you will be doing.”

02. What to pack

“The most important thing here is what you will wear when you wake up,” Cochrane says. “Something respectable is required even if it’s comfy. Then you want knitwear options, so you’re warm if the house is cold, but also something smart, like a button-down shirt if they crank up the heating; socks without holes; a good coat for a Christmas Day walk. Christmas jumpers are probably a bit much, but perhaps something in a seasonal colour for the big day.”

“The general dress code is elevated casual, with an emphasis on comfort,” Salerno says. “Nothing too restrictive around the waist. Thanksgiving is a marathon, not a sprint, and you want to leave some breathing room for the pie. An elastic waistband and an oversized knit are the unsung heroes of Thanksgiving.” The same should be your first thought for other festivities.

03. If you’re being homebodies

Loafing around requires indoor clothes. You might be at ease, but there are still standards to maintain. Cochrane suggests “plain pieces – like a merino wool jumper or a classic shirt (ironed). If jeans, then not too knackered. Ditto hoodies: no holes or stains. You want to look at home but not actually what you wear at home.”

“You can’t go wrong with a slightly oversized knit sweater,” Salerno says. “My favourites are from Polo Ralph Lauren, TOTEME or Our Legacy. Classic, yet still interesting – and incredibly comfortable. Ensure you also pack something you can get dirty, too – it’s always nice to offer to help cook, clean (or bartend!).”

Rachel O-Williams, Assistant Personal Shopper at MR PORTER, suggests a matching set. “TOM FORD does this particularly well, with beautifully made cashmere tracksuits in gorgeous, understated tones,” she says. “It’s the perfect combination of looking put together without actually having to make much effort, which, when you’re lounging around someone else’s house, is really the goal.”

04. If outdoor pursuits are on the cards

“Definitely a good coat,” Cochrane advises for, say, a country walk. “Some shoes that will stand up to muddy fields, good socks and accessories such as a scarf and hat to keep you warm. You don’t want to look underprepared.”

“I’d swap out a few of your usual outerwear pieces for something with a little more technical knowhow,” O-Williams says. “You don’t have to go full expedition mode, either. A classic waxed-cotton jacket is a great starting point – it’ll see you through those unpredictable rain showers. For something a little more considered, look at mixed-material shell jackets that combine natural fabrics, such as wool, with down-filled panels. They offer plenty of warmth without adding unnecessary bulk. Moncler and Orlebar Brown both provide some particularly good options. The trick is to be prepared for the elements without looking as though you’re about to climb a mountain.”

05. Remember where you are

We often think of fashion trends as being fixed to time, but geography also plays its part. Certain ideas take a while to filter through. Which is a roundabout way of saying that the far-flung suburbs might not be ready for what the city dweller wears routinely.

While Cochrane suggests how “fashion” you dress in the provinces is a personal choice, “turning the volume down a bit is probably the way to go. Still wear what you love but perhaps combine it with something more muted.”

“Generally, I tone it down unless the occasion calls for it,” Salerno says. “A relaxed Aimé Leon Dore hoodie or an understated Acne Studios sweater lets me show I care about what I wear, without it being the centrepiece of conversation. After all, I’m not walking a runway, I’m playing Scrabble and drinking a beer.”

But don’t let the environment entirely dictate your outfit. “You need to dress for your audience without losing your sense of self,” Salerno continues. “Looking put together means different things in different places. My suitcase looks completely different when I visit my mum in Miami to when I visit my partner’s family in Indiana. The former calls for a bit more TOM FORD and LOEWE, the latter Our Legacy and Ralph Lauren. Both are elevated, yet entirely different – and still remain true to me.”

“If you’re up for the ribbing, go with the Enfants Riches Déprimés distressed denim by all means,” Cochrane says.

06. Get your trousers right

The runways might be prepping us for the return of skinny jeans, but out in the sticks, last season’s wide-leg trousers have not even landed yet. So, where does that leave you and your legs?

“I always think the sweet spot is somewhere in the middle,” O-Williams says. “You can’t go wrong with a good pair of straight-leg trousers. It’s one of those fits that works with almost everything and never really dates. It’s also incredibly easy to work into your existing wardrobe, whether you’re wearing it with a chunkier knit, a relaxed shirt or something tailored. You get a modern silhouette without going too far in either direction.”

07. Don’t forget the gift

“The best accessory?” asks the stylist Lily Montasser, in reference to visiting your in-laws. “Walking in with a gift in hand.”

But what to give them? “If food or booze, not from the petrol station or supermarket (obviously check allergies and if they drink),” Cochrane says. “Go a bit artisan. Or another – maybe more unexpected – option could be an ornament for the tree.” A good tip for Christmas.

“If you’re struggling for inspiration, my go-to recommendation is always an elevated board game,” O-Williams says. It is, after all, a gift you’ll likely make use of while you’re there – and can diffuse tension (or perhaps build on it). “Something beautifully crafted, such as a burr maple backgammon set, makes for a particularly thoughtful gift. They’ll treasure it for years, but it’s also made to be enjoyed. Perfect for bringing out when you visit, sharing a little friendly competition and, hopefully, creating a few lasting memories along the way.”

“I’d opt for something for the home they’ll get plenty of use out of long after Thanksgiving,” Salerno says. “Elevated barware or a gorgeous decanter, ideally accompanied by a good bottle of wine. It’s hard to go wrong with a gift that encourages your hosts to keep pouring. Particularly if you’re hoping to be invited back next year.” That’s thinking ahead.